Is it Better to Forgive Than to Receive? An Empirical Analysis of the Impact of Mass Debt Repudiation

Randall Kroszner, Norman R. Bobins Professor of Economics

This project studies the consequences of large-scale debt relief in order to examine theories of debt overhang and the costs of financial distress. An analysis of this episode also is relevant to debates over debt restructuring policies both domestically and for countries that have experienced sharp currency devaluations, including 1997 Asia crisis, the Argentine “pesofication” of debt contracts in 2001, and the “debt exchange program” in Ghana in 2022-23. When the U.S. went off the gold standard and devalued the dollar with respect to gold in the early 1930s, the government declared that the courts would no longer enforce gold indexation clauses that were contained in virtually all long-term private and public debt contracts. If the gold clauses had been enforced, the debt burden of borrowers would have increased by the extent of the devaluation, which was 69 percent. The project will examine asset price responses to the Supreme Court’s decision to uphold this effective debt forgiveness in order to assess costs of financial distress.