Scenes of residential and commercial activity

Sam Peet

Urban Zoning Is Costing Americans a Fortune

Research estimates that reducing land-use restrictions would increase the welfare of urban residents by an average of about 9 percent.

In the United States, urban residents go about their lives amid cityscapes largely segregated into residential and commercial districts. Thanks to zoning laws, many people wake up in one area, and then commute to another for work.

Such zoning imposes large economic costs. The problem is not just that neighborhoods are segregated by function, but that the segregation is often backward: Land zoned for housing in many American cities would generate higher economic returns as commercial space, while commercial districts occupy areas where residents would be willing to pay a premium to live. Zoning locks land into its second-best use.

Why does it persist? Proponents argue it corrects market failures—separating noisy, polluting commercial activity from residential neighborhoods. But new research by Harvard PhD student Yu-Hsin Ho, Chicago Booth’s Chang-Tai Hsieh, Academia Sinica’s Wen-Tai Hsu, and Washington University in Saint Louis PhD student Yu-Jhih Luo finds that these justifications explain only a small fraction of actual zoning patterns. Their study suggests that the economic costs of US zoning laws are steep and outweigh any benefits.

The researchers sought to evaluate what goals US zoning serves and to measure its costs. While abundant empirical literature has documented how US zoning restricts building supply and thus raises prices, Ho, Hsieh, Hsu, and Luo focused on how zoning restricts the use of a particular structure for residential or commercial activities.

To quantify those effects, the researchers found a natural benchmark in the Taiwanese metropolis of Taipei, which does not impose a strict separation between residential and commercial activities, making it comparable to a city with effectively no zoning. They compared property-level data on residential and commercial floor space in Taipei with similar data for 34 US metropolitan areas, restricting their analysis to neighborhoods with a minimum density for either population or employment.

Land-use restrictions keep homes and businesses apart

Taipei neighborhoods tend to be less specialized into residential and commercial uses than those in US metropolitan areas such as Detroit. The researchers’ model suggests zoning contributes to that difference.

They designed a model in which neighborhoods naturally develop on the basis of the amenities they offer. Areas with social amenities, such as parks, tend to attract residential activity. Those with a relative edge in production—such as proximity to a major train station, helpful for commuters—draw businesses. Zoning, through land-use restrictions, “creates wedges between residential and commercial uses that distort this allocation,” the researchers write.

From data on floor space, residents, and workers in each neighborhood, Ho, Hsieh, Hsu, and Luo inferred the size of zoning wedges—the gap between the shadow price of commercial and residential space that zoning creates.

They find substantially smaller zoning wedges in Taipei, where “mixed-use development is common, and most neighborhoods permit both housing and employment activities,” the researchers write. In the US, however, “residential neighborhoods contain relatively little employment activity, while employment centers contain relatively few residents.”

The researchers estimate that reducing land-use restrictions to bring zoning wedges closer to Taipei’s level would increase the welfare of US urban residents by an average of about 9 percent. The gains vary widely: Chicago, the most distorted city, would see a welfare improvement of over 30 percent, while San Jose, the least distorted, would gain about 3 percent.

The researchers conclude that some US zoning policies as written do seem to favor mixed-use activity, and perhaps were conceived by officials hoping to create pedestrian-friendly neighborhoods where residents both work at and frequent local businesses. However, “most zoning appears unrelated to the economic characteristics of neighborhoods that would justify intervention,” the researchers write.

A key idea in economics is that “if you let planners instead of markets decide the allocation of resources, you get misallocation,” says Hsieh. The findings support this, suggesting that zoning, however well-intentioned, can still be poorly targeted: Even zoning that nominally aims at mixing generates more segregation in practice, imposing large and unnecessary costs on urban residents.

More from Chicago Booth Review
More from Chicago Booth

Your Privacy
We want to demonstrate our commitment to your privacy. Please review Chicago Booth's privacy notice, which provides information explaining how and why we collect particular information when you visit our website.