The holiday table is a cherished institution, a time to relax, reconnect with loved ones, and, of course, temporarily jettison any health goals. For many of us, December is the month when we suspend long-term commitments to eating well and staying fit. Somewhere in the back of our minds, we reassure ourselves that once January arrives, we’ll restart our exercise routines, cut back on carbs, and undo the damage. But for the next few weeks? That feels unrealistic at best.
We may even recruit Western and Eastern philosophy to justify this approach. Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard argued that “purity of heart is to will one thing,” and Confucius is often credited with warning that the person who chases two rabbits catches neither. Their advice seems clear: Stop trying to keep your health goals top of mind during the holidays. Instead, enjoy the candy canes, eggnog, and latkes fully and without guilt.
But is that really the only option? Is a healthy, delicious holiday season truly an oxymoron? Absolutely not.
Whether you’re talking about a meal or life in general, navigating multiple goals is hard, and becomes even harder when those goals seem to conflict. The New York Times’s Cooking section contains more than 22,000 recipes, but a roundup of holiday meals billed as both healthy and delicious had only 26 options on it. This curated list surely wasn’t meant to be exhaustive, but it may reflect a quiet skepticism that food can, in fact, be both.
Goals can be in conflict. Consider the need to stay open-minded versus win an argument, for example, or to be present versus document everything for Instagram. The health-taste conflict is one of the most frequently experienced goal conflicts, and it’s one that’s challenging to shake off.
And yet, in nature, health and taste goals typically align. Something spoiled tastes bad, while what’s fresh tastes good. People’s tendency to think of foods as either healthy or tasty creates a selection bias, which is why, in our kitchens, health and taste seem negatively rather than positively correlated. Modern food-manufacturing practices fuel this illusory trade-off, as invented foods tend to be addictive and offer minimal nutritional value.
Once health and taste are integrated, pursuing one goal no longer seems to compromise the other.
To create goal harmony, we need to revise our perceptions so that our health and taste goals overlap. One way to do that is to highlight a third goal—of eating beautifully—that is positively associated with the other two.
Consider an experiment we conducted with Yale PhD student Eda Erensoy and Stanford PhD student Louise Lu in a Stanford cafeteria. In summer 2023, when students entered their dining hall, they saw a large poster inviting them to “Choose the most beautiful meal!” After selecting their food from a buffet with dozens of options, students who opted in to the experiment took a picture of their tray to share with us. We compared their choices with those of another group of participants who visited the same dining halls on different days and were simply invited to “Choose your meal!” and share a photo. We found that the food selected to create a beautiful meal was healthier (as rated by two independent registered nutritionists) yet no less tasty (as rated by the diners themselves) than the food selected without the aesthetic goal. The pursuit of eating a beautiful meal led diners to choose food that was healthier without compromising taste.
Beautiful food is often colorful and varied, the result of fruits, vegetables, and minimal processing. It also activates our taste buds, as every meal in a gourmet restaurant demonstrates.
Seeking out this type of food thus aligns otherwise conflicting health and taste goals. It creates harmony in our objectives. Once health and taste are integrated, pursuing one goal no longer seems to compromise the other. We know—from research conducted by Booth PhD student Jiabi Wang and Ayelet—that people who perceive harmony between their life goals report greater well-being and eagerness. In the context of eating, those who choose healthy options without sacrificing taste will be happier.
One limitation of the Stanford cafeteria experiment is that diners chose whether to participate only after learning their assigned condition—namely, whether they had been invited to create a beautiful meal or simply a run-of-the-mill one. It’s possible that people who opted to upload photos of their beautiful meals were already health conscious. But additional experiments that were part of this same research demonstrate comparable patterns when diners learned the instructions for meal selection only after committing to participate.
In our research, in every case, asking people to pursue beauty led them toward a healthier meal without compromising on taste.
We observed similar effects among 10- to 18-year-olds, who created healthier yet equally tasty party menus when asked to make them beautiful, compared with when no such goal was mentioned. We also saw these results when people planned meals for a specific venue, such as for home, a restaurant, or a cafeteria. Even when choosing candy, people opted for healthier options—such as dark chocolate over Snickers—when aiming for beauty. The only exception was when it came to selecting breakfast cereals: Those with the prettiest colors and shapes make breakfast look beautiful, but they are usually highly processed. Many find Froot Loops to be more beautiful than oatmeal, but oatmeal is healthier.
A beautiful meal still leaves considerable room for personal creativity and taste. For some, beauty in this respect means a variety of foods. For others, it means including colors or shapes. For still others, it reflects cultural identity or personal values. But in our research, in every case, asking people to pursue beauty led them toward a healthier meal without compromising on taste. And beauty, like taste, is intrinsically motivating. It heightens a diner’s enjoyment, and we eat not for long-term benefits but because doing so feels good. Eating beautiful food doesn’t require willpower or self-denial; it is pleasurable.
As the holidays settle into a familiar drift of casseroles, confections, and the comforting logic of beige (the palette of gravy, mashed potatoes, rolls, stuffing, and turkey), we encourage you to pause and add something beautiful to the table. A touch of color or variety does more than brighten a plate; it changes how we choose what to eat. Beauty creates a kind of goal harmony, letting celebration and health coexist. It changes eating well from a test of resolve into a source of pleasure. When January arrives, you may find the season leaves you not with regret but with the quieter satisfaction of having had meals—hopefully accompanied by wonderful conversations and other fulfilling moments—that were both healthier and more delicious.
Ayelet Fishbach is the Eric J. Gleacher Distinguished Service Professor of Behavioral Science and Marketing at Chicago Booth. Jennifer Aaker is the General Atlantic Professor at the Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- Eda Erensoy, Louise Lu, Jennifer Aaker, and Ayelet Fishbach, “Beauty as a Goal: Creating Harmony Between Health and Taste,” Journal of Consumer Research, October 2026.
- Jiabi Wang and Ayelet Fishbach, “Goal Harmony,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology: Attitudes and Social Cognition, April 2026.
Your Privacy
We want to demonstrate our commitment to your privacy. Please review Chicago Booth's privacy notice, which provides information explaining how and why we collect particular information when you visit our website.