Chicago Booth Review Podcast What Do You Want to Achieve in 2025?
- December 25, 2024
- CBR Podcast
It’s that time when we start to think about what we want to achieve in the coming year. What can you do to make sure that this year you stay motivated and focused on your goals? We ask two experts for advice: Chicago Booth’s Ayelet Fishbach, author of Get It Done: Surprising Lessons from the Science of Motivation, and University of Pennsylvania’s Katy Milkman, author of How to Change: The Science of Getting from Where You Are to Where You Want to Be.
Hal Weitzman: It is that time when we start to think about what we want to achieve in the coming year. Fast-forward a few months, and many of us will have abandoned our goals and slipped back to our old ways. So what can you do to make sure that this year you stay motivated and focused on your goals? Welcome to the Chicago Booth Review Podcast, where we bring you groundbreaking academic research in a clear and straightforward way. I'm Hal Weitzman.
Today, a conversation about how to set goals, stay motivated, and achieve your ambitions with Chicago Booth Ayelet Fishbach, author of Get It Done: Surprising Lessons from the Science of Motivation, and Wharton's Katy Milkman, author of How to Change: The Science of Getting from Where You Are to Where You Want to Be. The conversation was filmed in 2021 as part of our Big Question video series, which brings together Booth faculty with other experts for an in-depth discussion. I began by asking Ayelet Fishbach what advice she has for those of us who just feel overwhelmed and don't know where to start.
Ayelet Fishbach: It's very common at the moment. It has been an overwhelming experience for all of us for the last year and a half. So I would say if you are not overwhelmed, then you must be doing something very special. Things are constantly changing. We constantly need to adapt. I do a lot of work on how people manage their multiple goals, how do we balance between everything that we want to achieve. And it's harder when things are constantly changing, when we need to open the news in the morning and see how are we going to deal with things today. So I sympathize more into what do we know about how to deal with this.
Hal Weitzman: Okay, but you've written this fantastic book, which is coming out shortly, Get It Done. If you have a big goal you want to get done, but you are just overwhelmed and don't know where to start, what would be your advice?
Ayelet Fishbach: So I suggest in this book a framework that has four steps. Start by deciding what is it that you want to achieve, where do you want to get, what's the goal? And there are some techniques that we can use to set goals that actually work. Then have a plan to how are we going to get from here to there? Okay. How are we going to monitor our progress? How are we going to learn from feedback? Then think about everything else that is going on in your life. Okay, how are we going to pursue this goal that you listed, giving all the other goals that you want to achieve simultaneously, what supports it, what conflicts with it? And then the fourth component is social support. Who is in your life is going to help you achieve this goal?
Hal Weitzman: So I mean, you're actually talking about writing stuff down, right? Is getting this stuff down going to help you sort out what's important?
Ayelet Fishbach: Well, it certainly will help you start somewhere to know where you want to get. So yes, I encourage writing down what is it that you want to achieve.
Hal Weitzman: Okay, Katy Milkman, let me bring you in. You've also written a terrific book. What's your advice for people who are just at this time feeling completely overwhelmed about their situation and the things they want they want to get done, but they just don't know where to start?
Katy Milkman: Yeah, it's a great question. And by the way, I also want to say thank you for having me and what a treat it us to be here with Ayelet who I know we wrote separate books, but I think, well, her thinking has certainly influenced me immensely and her research makes many appearances in the book I wrote and has influenced me just more than I can really say. When I think about being overwhelmed and one thing that I can add to all the great advice that's already been shared, the thing that comes to mind is looking for a moment that might feel like a fresh start. So I've done a lot of research on the idea that there are some moments in our lives that stand out from others that feel like new beginnings. So they can be as small as the start of a new week or more momentous like the celebration of a major birthday at the start of a new year or a millennium.
Those moments give us a sense that we have closed one chapter and can open another and can help us take that deep breath we need when we're feeling overwhelmed, get the motivation to say, "Okay, that was the old me that was overwhelmed and couldn't achieve these goals and the new me maybe can do it in this new era." So I would say one thought given the evidence that those fresh starts can be motivating if you're feeling overwhelmed is can you identify a moment that might feel like a new beginning to you? Maybe you're about to return to work after a long time away. Maybe you're planning a vacation with your family and when you come back you could think of that as a fresh start and a moment when you want to actually do exactly what Ayelet just suggested. So write down those goals and so on. But you may be more motivated to do so, more able to deal with that overwhelming feeling if you can give your self the sense of a fresh start.
Hal Weitzman: And since you mentioned fresh starts, something that I worried about when I was reading your book is that it just becomes another delaying tactic. It's the old I'll begin the exercise regime next week, then on Monday morning it doesn't feel so good. So I'll begin next week. So how do you avoid that? Because as you say, there's always an opportunity for a fresh start.
Katy Milkman: Yeah, it's a great question. How do you avoid the constant delay is a great question. And honestly there are different tactics that I would propose for that. If you always have a fresh start coming and you're never actually beginning, that would be a problem. Our research suggests that doesn't seem to be the dominant way that fresh starts operate. The dominant way we use them is to gather motivation rather than to procrastinate. But when it comes to procrastination, that's a huge barrier to overcome in order to achieve our goals. And one of the most useful tactics for overcoming procrastination is actually setting firm commitments and using what's called a commitment device.
A commitment device is a tool where you basically treat yourself the way you would normally think of a government or a manager treating you give yourself deadlines, maybe with penalties associated with them for failing to achieve a goal. The firmer your commitment, the harder it is to back down and procrastinate. So there's even websites you can use like stickk.com and Beeminder where you can literally put money on the line that you'll be forced to forfeit if you fail to achieve a goal by a certain date and you can be held accountable for that by a referee who you name. And that really helps a lot procrastination because now you have a penalty that you're going to incur if you don't achieve your goal by a stated date. So that might be one tactic.
Hal Weitzman: Excellent. Now I dragged you straight into both of you straight into the weeds because we were responding to this poll about our participants today saying they feel overwhelmed, but I want to take a step back and reading these great books. There's a slightly different approach here. Ayelet Fishbach, you are focusing on motivation and as you say, how to set and achieve goals and targets. Katy Milkman, you are focusing on making change and getting rid of the obstacles that are standing in the way to that change. So I just wanted to ask you what made you come up with that particular approach to this issue?
Ayelet Fishbach: You captured it very well. Also, I want to clarify that Katy's amazing book is out there and so we can all read it. My book is-
Hal Weitzman: We can pre-order your book.
Ayelet Fishbach: Yeah, my book can be pre-ordered and I bet that is going to influence your life, but maybe reading it will have some extra benefit as well.
Hal Weitzman: Maybe the fresh start could be when your book arrives and then I'll get on with everything.
Ayelet Fishbach: Exactly. And so I had the advantage of reading Katy's book and it was very interesting for me because you would think that we are two people looking at the same world and so we will see exactly the same thing. And it's a bit like wondering how two painters created different painting given that they were looking at the same world. And we did come up with quite different paintings. I think that I was trying to see what I have learned in many years of writing about motivation and doing motivation research and what is the process by which people motivate themselves, where do they start? What happens next? And it was like these phases, can you start with the goal, but then you need to get from here to there? And then you need to look around at everything else that is going on. And I was trying to organize everything that I know in a framework that makes for me and that is useful. And then I will let Katy maybe explain what she was trying to achieve in her amazing book.
Katy Milkman: So I love the analogy of painters. We're familiar with the same research literatures. We've spent a lot of time talking and thinking about similar ideas, but ended up seeing different ways to communicate what came out of that and synthesize it for a broad audience. I think that at the heart of the book I wrote is the premise that it's really important to match the solution you're using to try to achieve change to whatever the obstacle is that might be standing in your way. And so that means a lot of tailoring. I actually think it's very complimentary to what you're saying, Ayelet, about having a staged approach because what I'm also acknowledging is that it depends. It depends you're thinking where you are in the process and I'm saying it depends on what your current barrier is. That may be very much a function of where you are in the process.
And I break it down into a series of particularly common obstacles that I've seen including the getting started problem and fresh starts are a big part of that. And then other barriers include procrastination, which we just mentioned, impulsivity, where Ayelet's research features really prominently into what I describe as a solution as well as forgetting. Laziness, which another kinder way of saying that is inertia and habit, which we need to be able to overcome. And then of course there's having a confidence to begin. And finally I talk about social support and how important that is, which I know is also a part of Ayelet's step-by-step process.
Hal Weitzman: Okay, excellent. And I'm glad, Katy Milkman, that you mentioned that it depends on the individual because you point out in your book, Ayelet Fishbach, that a lot of the evidence on behavioral motivation appears to be contradictory. So it's something to do with the situation, but it's also considerable amount to do with the individual. How do you know what kind of an individual you are, what your weaknesses are, where you've been going wrong? Because many of us have been doing the same thing over and over again, failing over and over again and we are sort of blind maybe to our own weaknesses or our own strengths. How do you identify those?
Ayelet Fishbach: Lots of self-reflection. When I teach our MBA students, I sometimes talk about it as the salt and pepper problem, which is if you cook some dish and it's missing pepper, then just don't add too much salt. It's not going to help. So very much along the lines of Katy said about identifying your barriers is self-reflecting on what is stopping you. And if you don't have social support, then it's really hard to do something. If I try to save money and I am married to someone who's spending a lot of money, it makes it very hard to do. But if I have the same goal, I want to save money and my family and friends and everybody else around me supports that, then I need to think about what else is going on. Okay. Do I also have conflicting goals? Am I just too vague in how exactly I'm going to pursue this one? So there is quite a bit of analysis of what works for me, what helps me achieve the goal and what stands in the way, and then making a plan that takes what I have into account.
Hal Weitzman: Okay. And are you suggesting, so if you have someone you can ask, "Where am I going wrong?" Presumably that helps. If you don't have someone, I mean you're suggesting that, again, you document what happened, what failed, do some reflection.
Ayelet Fishbach: Yeah. Well, first, if you don't have people that support your goal, then you have to find these people.
Hal Weitzman: Okay.
Ayelet Fishbach: Okay? I don't think very possible or at least extremely hard to do anything by yourself without social support. So if that's the problem, if you embark that goal and no one around you seem to support it, then get the support. It's like that college kids that find friends that will support their academic pursuits because being friends with those people that only like to party is not helping. But then on top of that, just figure out what's missing in your recipe for success.
Hal Weitzman: Got it. And presumably experiment with things that you haven't done before and see if they work.
Ayelet Fishbach: Great point, experiment. Okay. Katy and I strongly believe in experiments. Here's another point where we are on the same page. Try out things, be willing to fail.
Hal Weitzman: Okay, excellent. We have had some great questions coming in and please continue to send us your questions. I want to put one of these to you, Katy Milkman, from Leandro de Sar, and this essentially, how do you go beyond simple behavioral change that might not lead to permanent deep change? So you talked about fresh starts and I remember a period in my life when giving up smoking was easy, I did it 20 or 30 times. So how do I avoid getting that situation where I'm constantly having to make a fresh start and actually can make it a habit?
Katy Milkman: Yeah, it's a fantastic question. And by the way, I want to note that that is one of the biggest problems with the research we've done on the fresh start effect is that it doesn't take you very far. It gets you motivated to begin. And then we see that most goals actually fail after people begin, right? So most New Year's resolutions fail fairly quickly and that's why we need so much more scaffolding to build upon and so much more behavioral science than just that new beginning to kick things off. In terms of how we create enduring change, one of the things that I hoped to study in my career was that very question. And I will say for a while, I was looking for what I now think of as something like the fountain of youth, like a silver bullet solution. If we could just put people through this, give them this set of nudges for a few weeks, we could just change them forever after after we pulled back, we could build a habit that would last forever.
And I will say research on habits and the research I've done related to habits suggests that when we repeat a behavior, we're rewarded for that behavior over a long enough time period, enough repetitions, which it varies by context, maybe exercise you can repeat for a month or two months, something more micro like making yourself coffee doesn't take as long. Once you do that and you take the rewards away, some of the behavior does continue, and we know this from animal experiments that have shown the same kinds of patterns that we see in human behavior, but only maybe 30%. And if you take away whatever the tools and tactics are that are supporting change, and I know we're going to get into more of those shortly, most of the behavior actually extinguishes and what that has taught me is I don't think there is a silver bullet.
There isn't a month of programming you could go through that will carry you forward forever after if you just quit at that point and say, "Okay, I'm all set." What we need to do instead is build structures, build goal-setting plans, social support networks, feedback mechanisms and so on that stay with us so that we don't treat change as a short-term problem, but rather something we need to consistently work at that we need to consistently use the tools that behavioral science has proven can help us create change and think of this as something that we do day in, day out, month in and month out as opposed to temporarily in order to enact a change that will then last.
Ayelet Fishbach: Perfect example for the point that Katy just made about chronic change and about constantly needing to support. This is a form relationship goals. I think that most people intuitively understand that there is no one thing that you can do to have great relationship. You will have to come up with new things every now and then. You don't just do it once. But people sometimes make the mistake to think that for other goals such as a healthy eating or exercising, there is just a one thing that I can do and that will take me for the next 10 years and that just doesn't work like this. Speaking about how to move from a novice to an expert, one of the things that we looked at in our research is how people monitor their goals. And for novices, it's really good to look backward at how much you've done.
Okay? So if you can just run one mile or you've only done it for a month, look back and say, "Hey, I can already run one mile. I've already been doing it for a month." If you are a marathon runner or just a runner, if you feel that you are more of the expert, then look at what's missing. Look at the glass half empty and then you'll realize that, "Oh, well, I haven't been running enough this week. I should put on my gym shoes and go for one." It really helps at the beginning to look back, only then to look at what's missing, how far I am for where I want to be.
Hal Weitzman: That sounds a lot like your research on feedback, which is so interesting that when someone's new to a task, you encourage very positive, someone who's an expert and you give the story, Katy Milkman, you start talking about Andre Agassi. If you're an expert or professional, the type of coaching you want is very critical and very specific.
Ayelet Fishbach: Absolutely. So it's hard to learn from negative feedback. It's much easier to learn from positive feedback. The problem is that there is actually really good information in negative feedback. So while it's hard, we should be paying attention. But when we are new to something or where we are with the expert in the room, then it makes it even harder to learn from negative feedback. And this is why we give novices positive feedback and for ourselves when we start on something, we should really focus on getting positive feedback on seeing what I am doing right, encouraging yourself with the successes and later on open up to hear how you can still improve.
Hal Weitzman: I want to bring in another audience question. This is from Carly, and I apologize if I'm not saying your last name correctly, Kadlick. Is it difficulty in achieving personal goals that we create goals based on unrealistic expectations, which is they're just not practical and achievable for us?
Ayelet Fishbach: So a bit of optimism is actually pretty good. No personal example, high of the goal to exercise daily, and I don't quite reach it on most weeks. Okay. So I mean this is just way too optimistic, usually something happens there is at least one day that I miss and then that's fine. Okay. So it's better to set your goals so that they are a bit more optimistic than what is feasible then that they are not optimistic enough.
Hal Weitzman: You mean and then be kind to yourself that you didn't actually hit them.
Ayelet Fishbach: Exactly. But then if you reach 80% of the ambitious goal, that's fine. Okay. We only set these targets to motivate ourselves, so we should not be too tied up to them.
Hal Weitzman: But I wonder, listening to you speak about the way that you organize your goals, if they're not organized, you can say, "Well, I want to learn the piano, I also want to play football and I want to learn Spanish, whatever." So you just have too much and you haven't actually been forced to pick what is important is the prioritizing going to help you to organize these things and then make it more achievable because you think, "Okay, I'll leave Spanish and I'll focus on playing the piano."
Ayelet Fishbach: Absolutely. And my colleague here with Booth just told me this morning, Emily Vinn, that she created now two lists on her whiteboard, urgent goals and important goals. And the frustrating thing is that she found out that she was more on the urgent and the important shift a bit more to the important. Yeah, it starts with an organization.
Hal Weitzman: But I mean that's very practical, isn't it? What you just described. For example, on the email, we're often pulled into doing stuff that's urgent but not important and getting it out the way and then we find that the day is gone. Katy Milkman, I want to turn to you. I mean, same thing. Are we setting the bar too high? We know that from behavioral science research that people are usually hopelessly optimistic about lots of things. Do we tend to set the bar too high?
Katy Milkman: I completely agree with Ayelet's feedback on that, that it's important to have stretch goals. The research is very clear that we want to be setting the bar high for ourselves, and then the real challenge is that we aren't going to reach the bar quite and how do we deal with that? Ayelet pointed out that she's setting a tough goal for herself of exercising every day, but then she misses a couple of days and she's able to cope with it. I want to actually highlight some great research by my colleague Marissa Sharif at Wharton and also Suzanne Shu at Cornell that gives a very specific tactic we can use to not be too dissuaded when we set those stretch goals that are good for us, but inevitably make some mistakes. Marissa realized that she was having the exact same experience as Ayelet trying to run every day, but she couldn't quite get it done and sometimes she'd sort of throw up her hands and give up on the goal of running every day a week when she had a miss.
It's called the what the hell effect. And she came up with a really clever solution, which was she actually labels and allocates herself to emergency reserves whenever she has a goal of doing something seven days a week. And that turns out to be more effective than just saying, "I'm going to try not to give up on myself." Those emergency reserves are sort of chits. She only uses when she has a real disaster strike. So she doesn't take them just as she's feeling a little bit tired. It has to be something truly meaningful that gets in her way that she'll say, "All right, I'm going to use an emergency reserve. I'll still say I'm on track for my seven days this week. I get two of those allocated." And she's done research showing that giving people emergency reserves rather than ranges of goals or lower tier goals, even though they amount to exactly the same thing, those emergency reserves are more motivating because we don't want to dispatch them unless it's truly an emergency and it helps us also recover if we do have a failure and still feel that we're on track.
Hal Weitzman: If you're enjoying this podcast, there's another University of Chicago podcast network show that you should check out. It's called Nine Questions. Join Professor Eric Oliver as he poses the nine most essential questions for knowing yourself to some of humanity's wisest the most interesting people. Nine Questions with Eric Oliver, part of the University of Chicago podcast network. Both of you recommend tapping into intrinsic motivation, but if you just don't feel intrinsically motivated, can you develop it? Are intrinsic motivation just there or can you develop them?
Ayelet Fishbach: Well, intrinsic motivation is-
Hal Weitzman: Maybe just first describe what it is before we-
Ayelet Fishbach: Absolutely. Okay. So intrinsic motivation is when you do something as its own end, you do it because you want to do it. In the extreme or pure instances of intrinsic motivation, it's even weird to ask, why are you doing it? Because the only reason to do it is that I want to do it. It's a stroll in the park, it's eating that cake, it's sex as long as you're not doing it because you are trying to conceive. Most of the things that we do are not purely intrinsically motivated. I go to work partially because I need to get back, but I actually think that I'm pretty intrinsically motivated to do my job, which means that I am excited to do it and I tend to be sorry when the day is over. And there still so many things that I want to finish. So most of the time what we do is between being purely intrinsically motivated and not at all.
And then there are strategies that we both studied on how to increase intrinsic motivation. So I will let Katy talk about some of the amazing work that she did on how to add some sugar to your goals. I would say that we found that focusing on what you like about what you do, focusing on the intrinsically motivating aspects of that action are helpful. Focusing on some immediate rewards that you get from doing something, what is immediately gratifying is helpful. Often finding a way to do the same thing such that it feels more pleasant at the moment is the trick. So it's like finding the healthy food that you enjoy eating or finding the workout is most pleasurable for you and more strategies for you, Katy.
Katy Milkman: Yeah, and by the way, I just want to say I think this insight from your work really and your work also with Kaitlin Woolley is so important that so many of us a mistake and thinking if we have a goal to pursue, we'll just go for it, try the most effective way to get there. And we don't appreciate that the experience in the moment of goal pursuit. If it's not enjoyable, we will quit. So we need to find a fun way to pursue our goals. I think it's so important and maybe the most important insight about behavior change that there is. And actually before I knew about that research because it hadn't yet been done, I did something I'll say that I think of as a bit narrower, but that achieves the same end, which was I tried it myself and then I studied and it was me search.
I did something called I call temptation bundling. This will be familiar to some people who probably used it themselves. I realized if I could make a chore more pleasant by linking it with something I enjoyed, I would get the chore done more often. So for me as a graduate student, I found it to be a bit of a chore to get to the gym. It was hard for me to motivate myself to exercise. And my guilty pleasure when I should have been doing my problem sets was binge-watching TV or reading tempting novels. So I came up with a solution, I temptation bundled. I only let myself enjoy those indulgences, indulgent entertainment, while I was exercising at the gym. And suddenly I found myself craving trips to the gym to get my entertainment fix in, the time would fly while I was there, and then I'd come home motivated and ready to do my work because there were no distractions.
I'd already gotten to do the thing that would normally be the temptation pulling me away. So I realized it could use this tactic in lots of other settings as well. So you can only let yourself listen to your favorite podcast while you're doing household chores or only open your favorite bottle of wine while making a home-cooked meal. Only pick up the snack you most crave or the coffee you love when heading to hit the books at the library. Lots of ways we can do it. And we've studied it with exercise and found that if you essentially hold people's entertainment hostage so they can only access it at the gym, it increases the amount that they visit. But again, you can use this more broadly and I think it ties really nicely to Ayelet and Kaitlin's really critical insight about if we make it fun, this is just one way to make it fun, then we persist much longer. So it's really important to try to engineer solutions that make it enjoyable to do whatever normally feels like a chore.
Ayelet Fishbach: And Katy, can you say something about the Mary Poppins effect so that my comment on the sugar will not seem completely obscure?
Katy Milkman: Yes. In my book, I write about this idea as relating to the Mary Poppins insight that a spoonful of sugar makes the medicine go down. So if you bundle that spoonful of sugar, which in the case of my exercise, the spoonful of sugar was entertainment, right? Binge-watching Bridgerton say while you're at the gym, that makes the chore no longer feel like a chore that the spoonful of sugar makes the medicine go down pleasurably.
Hal Weitzman: I want to turn to something that both of you mentioned in your books, and I think that I'm right in saying both of you have been involved in research around this idea, which is this remarkable finding that advising or mentoring other people can actually help motivate you and make you better. So talk about that and how does it actually work?
Ayelet Fishbach: Yeah, that has. So it turned out that when you give advice, well, given that you believe yourself more than anybody else will believe you, you are very persuaded by your own advice. And so for me, working with students and constantly trying to explain to others how to do certain things, I don't know how much I influenced them, but I certainly influenced myself in research that I have a paper with Lauren Eskreis-Winkler and Angela Duckworth, and then Katy has another paper with the same co-authors that looked at this advising effect. What we found is that even if you ask people who feel that they don't know something to give advice, that will motivate them. So for example, we ask people that were looking for a job, these are unemployed people to give advice on how to get a job. The first respond is usually like, "Who am I to-"
Hal Weitzman: You ask unemployed people to give other unemployed people advice.
Ayelet Fishbach: On how to get a job. Okay. So they first respond is, "Well, I don't have a job. How can I give you advice on how to get a job?" But then you say, "Well, I think that you actually know something. Okay, you've been in the situation, what would you say?" And people give good advice and they find their own advice much more motivating for them than reading the expert's advice. So maybe this is not something that I should say here because maybe then people will listen less to me and more to the advisor than that they give to themselves. But taking this risk, I would say give yourself advice.
Hal Weitzman: Okay, excellent. And Katy Milkman, how does that apply to a team set, an office setting where I might say, well, somebody who's struggling, I might say she should give advice to another staff member, another employee, and that will help motivate her and get her more engaged.
Katy Milkman: That's right. Yeah. So the really interesting implication of this work that Lauren Eskreis-Winkler has been leading that Ayelet and I have both gotten to be involved with is that sometimes when someone is struggling, you can help them most by putting them the position of a mentor. And I think for instance, Alcoholics Anonymous knows this, right? They not only assign you a sponsor when you join their program to help you have social support, but the sponsor is actually getting a benefit by being a mentor as well. So I think it's a tool we use too infrequently. There's another tactic that you can use to help yourself that Ayelet and I should really run an experiment on this, but it's a natural outgrowth of what we're both saying here, and I've used it in my life and found it hugely helpful, which is to form an advice club of similar minded people with similar goals.
You can gain social support from a group of people who are all trying to achieve a similar goal, but need someone to ping when they're not sure exactly how to approach a new challenge that arises. And I've done this in my professional life. I have a group of women who are at similar stage in their careers with similar career goals. When we get a request to do something, we're not sure whether or not this is the right use of our time or how to respond. We ping each other and it has two values.
Even though I initially only saw one, I initially thought, wow, this is so great. It's like friendship and free consulting from brilliant people to help me think through my problems. But what I've recognized over the years is not only am I getting those huge benefits, but whenever I am pinged and have to think about a problem that a colleague is facing who has similar career goals, I'm preparing for facing that myself. And the advice I give ends up influencing my own decisions in the long run and building my confidence that I can actually figure out great ways to handle these kinds of challenges. So I think advice clubs are probably something we should use more, given the dual benefit of that social support and the advice giving that you do and how that improves your own outcome.
Hal Weitzman: I just wanted to ask you very quickly to dig into the science there was actually going on. You talked about it a little bit, Katy, but is it just that by articulating what I think you should do, I'm more likely to do it? What's the mechanism there?
Katy Milkman: It's great.
Ayelet Fishbach: Oh, Katy, go on.
Hal Weitzman: Go ahead, Katy Milkman.
Katy Milkman: Ayelet, I'm sure, would give it the same answer to this one. I'm sorry if I am chiming in out of turn. This is in the book I wrote, I focus on this as a particularly useful tool when confidence is a barrier to change. And one of the reasons I think it's so useful in that context is that when you're asked for advice, it boosts your confidence. It makes you believe, oh, someone thinks that I'm worthy of reflecting on this, of coaching others on this. And so if you were previously lacking confidence, and Ayelet gave the great example of someone who is out of work and is trying to find a job, they may not believe in themselves and think this isn't going to go well, but someone comes along and says, "You know, I think you know a lot. I think you could give advice." That's a big ego boost and that could be helpful.
And then once they start introspecting, they're going to discover they do actually have that knowledge. This is what the research is showing. People do have insights, they just might not be motivated enough to dredge them up unless they have to articulate them for someone else. And then, of course, there's the saying is believing effect. Once you give this advice to someone else, you're more likely to believe it because it came out of your own mouth, and you don't want to feel like a hypocrite and not take the advice. So all of those mechanisms, I suspect, are pooled and make this such a powerful tool for changing behavior.
Hal Weitzman: Katy Milkman, what are your thoughts about removing the barriers to changing an organization, making a whole organization behave differently?
Katy Milkman: Maybe one thing to point to that we haven't talked much about, we've talked about social support, but I want to mention the great work on social norms and how conveying that everyone else is doing X can be really informative and influential if you are trying to convince a few folks who aren't toeing the line to also change their behavior in that direction. For instance, telling people, "Look, the majority of your peers are reusing..." This is kind of a funny example, but I do love this study. "They're reusing their towels at the hotel you're staying in, increases the likelihood you'll reuse your towels too." Which it seems like a funny thing, but just learning that everyone else is doing it does two things. One, it makes it seem like, "Oh, this is normal. I thought maybe it was a weird behavior, but I guess it's not."
And it also, it can make you feel like I don't want to be the oddball. And in an organization where there's lots of people that peer pressure can be a powerful and useful tool to leverage. It's also important to note that there's lots of ethical considerations. You could see this being used for evil. And in fact, it was first studied by social psychologists who are trying to understand how the Nazis created so much conformity in so many regular people. So it's an important and powerful tool, but also one that can be wielded irresponsibly. So we have to be thoughtful, very thoughtful and careful about that.
But I do think social influence and recognizing its power is useful to organizational leaders who are trying to create change. And there's new research showing that you don't even need to be able to point to and say, "Hey, look, the majority of your peers are doing X to change behavior." You can just show an increasing trend and say, "Look, 20% were engaging in remote work one day a week before, and now it's up to 40%." And even though it's still not the majority, seeing that trend turns out to propel people to change their behavior in the direction of that, it's called an increasing social norm. So that's a tool that may be particularly useful to mention.
Hal Weitzman: Okay. Excellent. Thank you. I do want to get to this question that came in from Michaela Saviano, "Please discuss mommy guilt." Mommy guilt being presumably the idea that or daddy guilt, you're not being a good parent.
Ayelet Fishbach: Well, all the three of us are parents. That means that all the three of us are probably guilty at times. This is a great example for goal conflict. But what we know is that people can either see their goals as conflicting with each other or as complementing each other. And I personally think that the best way to deal with guilt is to remind yourself that by finding the right balance between your parenting goal, your professional goals, your social goals, seeing friends, your traveling goals, you are actually a better parent. These tend to complement each other. Okay? I'm a better employee because I have life outside of work because I have perspective. I'm a better parent to my children because I was able to raise them to believe that a parent, and in particular a mom, can have a career and family and hobbies and a bunch of other things. So my personal advice is think about this more as complementing goals.
Hal Weitzman: But I wonder, I mean, given the experience that many of us have had working from home, but also the experience that's been going on for many, many years of that work never stops. You get emails and the expected to respond to stuff in the evening. And much as we might have the best intentions of putting the phone away whereas soon as we get home, it's just very hard to do that. It's not to mention that the way that the phone is set up is designed not to do that. I mean, to what extent is this just a state of the fact that we feel that we're multitasking more and more and we don't have time for the things that are really important.
Ayelet Fishbach: So asking Katy or me about work-life balance is kind of asking the poor on how to save money.
Hal Weitzman: Well, according to you, that's what we should be doing.
Ayelet Fishbach: Exactly right. So this is when I give advice on the thing that I don't do.
Hal Weitzman: So let's try and help you.
Ayelet Fishbach: In my mind, these calls often support each other. I try to make sure that I do what I'm most excited about. So it might not be email, but I will work on my book over the weekend when I'm probably supposed to do something else with my family. I'm very forgiving and not trying to be forgiving to others and to myself, try to do what's important, not necessarily what urgent, try to balance between everything, but not just don't be too judgmental. Okay. It's hard. And there are-
Hal Weitzman: You mean of oneself?
Ayelet Fishbach: Yes, yes. Or you of me.
Hal Weitzman: Yeah. Right. Katy Milkman, any thoughts on mommy guilt or parental guilt?
Katy Milkman: Well, I think Ayelet put it beautifully when she said that these are complementary goals. I guess I'd add a couple of tactics that might be useful to think about. One is that I talked about commitment devices earlier where we can sort of treat ourselves the way we're used to. We're used to somebody finding us if we speed somebody else imposing rules on us. But it's a little funny to think about imposing rules on ourselves, and yet that can be really useful when you anticipate goal conflict, when you anticipate temptations getting in the way of doing what you know is in your best interest is to set up structures that will create boundaries. So when you're in the heat of the moment and you're tempted to look at your phone, it's harder to do. So for instance, you can make sure the phone is in another room when you are having a meal with your family, so that even if you're tempted to pick it up and then get sucked into a work funnel, it's not easily available or accessible.
I went on a short vacation to celebrate an anniversary with my spouse recently, and I wanted to have my phone so that if there was an issue, my child wasn't with us, but we could get contacted right away if there was an issue. But I moved my email off of my phone during that trip so I wouldn't be tempted to look. So you could be strategic about what you have access to when you know a temptation could be a problem, you can eliminate it from the situation. And then the other thing I would say is there's some wonderful work on two topics that can help make transitions. One suggests that commutes are useful because they're a ritual that helps us transition from one stage to another.
And we may want to insert other rituals into life if we're not commuting to help make those transitions. Pacing around our office a few times, listening to some music to cool to transition from one stage to another can be helpful and shutting down one part of life and going the other. And then there's research showing if we treat weekends like vacations, think of it as if it's a vacation, that can help you do things that are more fun, which we know is great for so many reasons and get more recharge during that time away.
Hal Weitzman: Excellent. Okay. Well, I think we're coming up to final question. So there's one thing I wanted to ask you because we were talking about advice so much. I wanted to ask you, what is the one piece of advice you give either in your book or generally that you find hard yourself to take?
Ayelet Fishbach: Oh gosh. Can Katy go first?
Hal Weitzman: Katy, you want one?
Ayelet Fishbach: I'll think about something.
Hal Weitzman: Should I have given you a minute to... I didn't give you a heads-up on this question, so should I give you a minute to think about it? Maybe I can say while you are thinking about that, maybe what I'll do is I'll pre thank the audience. So unfortunately, this is going to be our last question. So thank you very much for joining us. This has been a great discussion, and I did want to say thank you also for your questions. If you are interested in hearing more about research and behavioral science, economics, accounting, finance, marketing, everything else that we study here at Chicago Booth, I do want to encourage you to come to the Chicago Booth Review website at review.chicagobooth.edu where you can find great videos, summaries of research, feature articles, and lots of other material that will help you keep abreast of academic research in lots of different fields. Okay. I hope that was enough time for you guys to think about what you were going to say. Katy Milkman, what's the one piece of advice that you find it hard to take?
Katy Milkman: One thing that I have found surprising is that most of us underappreciate the importance of memory to achieving our goals that we often just forget to do things that we intend to do, and that can be a real disruptor. And there's research that I and others have done showing that we undervalue having reminders and structure to make sure that we won't slip up. And I think I'm guilty of this. I've created more and more structure around recognizing that I can't live without my calendar, and if someone else doesn't tell me to do it or if I'm not reminded to do it, it won't get done. But I think that's the one I slip up on the most and regret. And that making sure that we don't rely on our own memory for follow-through is a really important one and a tough one for me.
Hal Weitzman: Okay. That seems like a great one. As someone who often forgets from one room to the other while I went into that room, I think that's a great... I have time to write it in the calendar. Ayelet Fishbach?
Ayelet Fishbach: I say learning from failure and negative feedback. I know I should. I know there was a ton of good information there, and every time my paper gets rejected, I just push it away. They just take way too much time to recover and actually learn from the feedback.
Hal Weitzman: That's it for this episode of the Chicago Booth Review Podcast. If you want to learn more and test your knowledge about the science of motivation, take our tiny course, five video modules and quizzes you can complete in less than an hour. You can find it on our website at chicagobooth.edu/review. When you're there, sign up for our weekly newsletter so you never miss the latest in business-focused academic research. This episode was produced by Josh Stunkel. If you enjoyed it, please subscribe, and please do leave us a five-star review. Until next time, I'm Hal Weitzman. Thanks for listening, and from all of us at Chicago Booth Review, have a very happy, healthy, successful, and motivated New Year.
Your Privacy
We want to demonstrate our commitment to your privacy. Please review Chicago Booth's privacy notice, which provides information explaining how and why we collect particular information when you visit our website.