(light music)
Nicholas Epley: So for about the last 20 years, I’ve been interested in trying to figure out what seems like a fundamental paradox right at the core of human life. That paradox is that, on the one hand, we’re highly social creatures. We’re made happier when we reach out and connect with other people. We’re healthier when we reach out and are connected positively with other people. And yet, if you look around a little bit, there are all kinds of opportunities we have to connect with other people that we seem not to take. We have kind thoughts we could pass along to other people that we don’t share. We feel gratitude for somebody that we don’t express.
One thing that we find explains, I think at least in part, why it is we might on the one hand be highly social, made happier when we reach out and connect, and yet be reluctant to do it, is that we tend not to be optimistic enough about how positively other people will respond when we reach out to connect with them. One really good example of this, I think, is expressing gratitude.
(light music) (papers rustling)
[Talking to class] If you want to go out and have a good day, best way to do that, or a very good way to do that, is to think about, “How do I make somebody else’s day?” And writing a gratitude letter is a darn good way to make somebody else’s day. Question is, why aren’t you doing these things already? Why aren’t these habits for us already? Maybe for some of us they are, but these are all things that we have the opportunity to turn into habits that we don’t. My guess is that many of you would not have written a gratitude letter if I had not asked you to do it, or prompted you to do it. My guess is that many of us have people who we feel grateful to, but we haven’t expressed that to them. We haven’t told them that we feel grateful to them. Why do those people even exist out in our world? Why are we not expressing gratitude?
(gentle music)
Did you know how your recipient would feel? You knew the recipient would respond positively. They responded even more positively than you thought they would.
This one’s perhaps most interesting. You thought they’d feel great; they felt even greater than that. And you thought it would be a little awkward for the recipient; it turns out receiving a note with somebody telling you how much you’re grateful for them, that is just not awkward at all. The majority of people here give the highest possible response on the scale. That is what making somebody feel really damn good looks like right there.
“Energized, encouraged, and inspired.”
“Receiving this letter made my week.”
“It was a wonderful surprise.”
“It made me feel great and grateful.”
“Really good. I teared up a little bit.”
“Proud, honored, eager to invest further.”
One of your recipients said, “Being appreciated for who you are as a person is the highest form of compliment you can receive. I feel this is the reason why this world is still worth living in and kindness still worth something.”
Sometimes these little things, you just don’t know where you’re gonna meet somebody in their life. You don’t know the moment when you’re gonna connect with them in a way that’s gonna have an impact on them. It’s not just about this little thing that you did, but that’s something much bigger.
(gentle music)
[Talking to camera] So one of the reasons why this happens is that the lens that we view ourselves through is different from the lens that other people view us through. We tend to think about ourselves in terms of our agency, our competency, our capabilities. Are we doing this effectively or not?
Other people tend not to view us only through that. They also view us through our warmth. They care how kind, how decent, how honest, how friendly, how trustworthy we are.
Think about how you feel when you first sit down to express your gratitude to somebody, right? You’re writing a letter. What’s the first thing that comes to your mind? It’s not how nice this will be. It’s, “Oh my gosh, what am I gonna say? How am I gonna get the words right? How am I gonna take this massive feeling that I have for somebody and put it into words in a way that does it justice?”
We worry about the words. We worry about the content: “Am I articulate enough? Am I getting the words right?” The recipients, they care about that, but not nearly as much as the kindness, the love, the gratitude that you are expressing, the warmth that you are conveying. That’s dominant for them.
So if we’re looking at this through a lens of competency, while other people are looking at it through a lens of warmth, we’re gonna tend to underestimate, particularly when something is really high on warmth, how positive that experience is gonna be received.
(gentle music)
It’s not that researchers aren’t guilty of doing this very same thing too. I have done this myself, had people who I appreciate deeply but who I haven’t expressed gratitude to, for exactly the same reasons that the people in our research also don’t express their gratitude.
I was caught, in fact, doing this on a podcast one time on “Hidden Brain,” where they asked me during the interview, “Is there somebody, Nick, who you feel really grateful to who you haven’t reached out and expressed your gratitude to?” And in fact, there was. Right away, instantly, somebody popped into my head, and that person was my high school band teacher, Craig Aune.
[Talking to class] And he was phenomenal. He was phenomenal at getting the best out of students who didn’t really want to be there, like me. I was a tuba player. I was not an all-star tuba player, was not an amazing musician by any means. I was a football player in high school and a basketball player, and the girl-to-guy ratio was pretty good in the band when it came to football player. So it was a pretty good place to be.
But nevertheless, he got the best out of us in amazing ways. Every student who was in his class in our band can close their eyes and hear his voice screaming enthusiastically from the top of the bleachers. And when I come into the classroom, I try to channel him. That’s who comes to mind when I think about the kind of teacher I want to be.
And it had been 30 years since I’d been in my high school band, and I had never reached out and told him that.
[Talking to camera] And why hadn’t I done that? Well, it would be weird. It’d be awkward. It’d been . . . so much time had passed, and I don’t really know how to connect with him. All these things, barriers that were getting in the way that I knew from my research were mistaken, and yet even I hadn’t overcome them.
So after this podcast, I did. I got from a friend of mine—thanks, Todd Jones—I got Mr. Aune’s email address, his text number as well, and I sent him a text message saying how much I appreciate him, how I’d been thinking about him all these years before almost every class I go into, and yet I hadn’t reached out to him, and that I would love to talk to him.
I almost instantly got a message back saying, “Nick, I’m sitting in a park right now, not far from my house, in tears, reading your note. I would love to talk.”
[Talking to class] It was possibly the best 30-minute conversation I’ve had with any single individual. It was absolutely lovely.
And then you wonder, why didn’t I do this? Why did I keep this to myself for so long? That seems kind of dumb.
[Talking to camera] I think the answer is you don’t need to. And once you start realizing that these bars that we have in our minds that keep us, that create barriers from reaching out and engaging with other people aren’t made of steel, but are more like pasta noodles. They’re miscalibrated in certain ways. It’s empowering. It’s empowering. It shows you how quite easily, without exerting a whole lot of unpleasant or miserable effort, we can live better lives by being a little bit more social. (uplifting music)